Independent birding guide — not affiliated with the original Bird-a-Day challenge or the domain's previous owner.
Birdaday Field Notes

ID guide

Types of red birds in US yards: 12 cardinals, tanagers, finches and more compared

Updated

The red bird at most US feeders is the Northern Cardinal: red all over, with a crest and a black face, and present all year from the East to the desert Southwest (All About Birds, Audubon). The other red birds a backyard birder sees are the streaky red finches (House, Purple and Cassin's Finch, and the Red Crossbill); two summer tanagers that stay high in the trees; and, regionally, the Pyrrhuloxia and Vermilion Flycatcher of the Southwest and the Painted Bunting of the southern states. The Red-winged Blackbird and Red-headed Woodpecker carry red on a black-and-white body.

The chart sorts all twelve by size, where the red sits on the bird, region and season, and what brings them to a yard. Most of them get their red from food: All About Birds says birds can't make bright red or yellow colors directly (see why red birds are red).

Jump to: Chart · Sizes · Red bird with black wings? · Northern Cardinal · Pyrrhuloxia · Summer Tanager · Scarlet Tanager · House Finch · Purple Finch · Cassin's Finch · Red Crossbill · Painted Bunting · Vermilion Flycatcher · Red-winged Blackbird · Red-headed Woodpecker · Why red · Attracting red birds

Types of red birds chart: size, where red, range and feeder food

Bird Length Where the male is red Female Where and when in the US What brings it to a yard
Northern Cardinal 8.3–9.1 in Red all over, crest, black face around a reddish bill Pale brown, red tinges in wings, tail and crest All year; abundant in the Southeast, north into southeastern Canada, mostly absent west of the Great Plains but locally common in the desert Southwest Black-oil sunflower and safflower on trays or hoppers
Pyrrhuloxia 8.3 in Gray, with red face and crest, a red stripe down the breast and a reddish tail; yellow bill Buffy gray with less red All year in desert scrub and mesquite of the Southwest and Texas Sunflower, often on the ground or scattered
Summer Tanager 6.7 in Entirely red, pale bill Yellow-green, yellower below Spring to fall; open oak and pine woods in the Southeast, streamside cottonwoods and willows in the Southwest No feeder food listed; berry bushes and fruit trees
Scarlet Tanager 6.3–6.7 in Red body, black wings and tail (spring and summer) Olive-yellow, darker olive wings and tail Spring and summer in large eastern deciduous forests; backyards in migration No feeder food listed; berry plantings
House Finch 5.1–5.5 in Rosy red around the face and upper breast; some males orange or yellow Plain grayish-brown, thick blurry streaks All year; native to the West, introduced in the East in 1940 and now in most neighborhoods Small black-oil sunflower
Purple Finch 4.7–6.3 in Evenly washed with dull red on head and foreparts, no dark side stripes No red; dark whisker, whitish eyebrow Breeds in the North and along the Pacific Coast; erratic at feeders in winter Black-oil sunflower
Cassin's Finch 6.3 in Rosy pink, brightest red on a peaked crown Crisply streaked brown and white Western mountain conifer forests; lower in winter Mostly buds and conifer seeds; on FeederWatch's common feeder birds list
Red Crossbill 5.5–6.7 in Brick red, darker wings and tail; crossed bill tips Yellowish below, olive-brown above Mature conifer forests in mountains and the boreal forest; nomadic, wandering south in irruptions Conifer seeds; sometimes sunflower, especially in the West
Painted Bunting 4.7–5.1 in Red underparts and rump, blue head, green back Bright yellow-green, pale eyering Breeds in the coastal Southeast and south-central US; some winter in Florida Seeds at feeders in yards with low, dense shrubs
Vermilion Flycatcher 4.8–5.4 in Brilliant orange-red, with a dark brown mask, back, wings and tail Gray-brown, faint breast streaks, salmon-red blush below The Southwest, mostly near water; small numbers winter along the Gulf Coast No feeder food; catches flying insects from low perches
Red-winged Blackbird 6.7–9.1 in Glossy black with scarlet-and-yellow shoulder patches Streaky brown, like a large dark sparrow All year in many areas; marshes and fields, northern migrants back early in spring Mixed grains and seeds scattered on the ground
Red-headed Woodpecker 7.5–9.1 in Whole head red; white underparts, black back with big white wing patches Same (sexes alike); young birds have brown heads Open woods, farmland and towns of the East and Plains; northern and western birds winter in the Southeast Occasionally suet in winter

Lengths and plumage: All About Birds (Cornell Lab of Ornithology) identification pages; Red Crossbill length and Purple Finch plumage from Audubon's field guide. Range, season and food: All About Birds species overviews and Audubon's field guide; Cassin's Finch feeder status from Project FeederWatch. A "female" cell describes adult females; young birds differ.

Red bird sizes compared

Lengths of twelve red backyard birds on one inch scaleHorizontal bars on a 4 to 10 inch scale, numbered 1 to 12 in the order of the chart: 1 Northern Cardinal 8.3 to 9.1 inches; 2 Pyrrhuloxia 8.3 inches; 3 Summer Tanager 6.7 inches; 4 Scarlet Tanager 6.3 to 6.7 inches; 5 House Finch 5.1 to 5.5 inches; 6 Purple Finch 4.7 to 6.3 inches; 7 Cassin's Finch 6.3 inches; 8 Red Crossbill 5.5 to 6.7 inches; 9 Painted Bunting 4.7 to 5.1 inches; 10 Vermilion Flycatcher 4.8 to 5.4 inches; 11 Red-winged Blackbird 6.7 to 9.1 inches; 12 Red-headed Woodpecker 7.5 to 9.1 inches. A single published length is drawn as a short marker. Cardinal and Pyrrhuloxia dark red, tanagers scarlet, finches rose, other families purple.4 in5 in6 in7 in8 in9 in10 in123456789101112
  1. Northern Cardinal, 8.3–9.1 in
  2. Pyrrhuloxia, 8.3 in
  3. Summer Tanager, 6.7 in
  4. Scarlet Tanager, 6.3–6.7 in
  5. House Finch, 5.1–5.5 in
  6. Purple Finch, 4.7–6.3 in
  7. Cassin's Finch, 6.3 in
  8. Red Crossbill, 5.5–6.7 in
  9. Painted Bunting, 4.7–5.1 in
  10. Vermilion Flycatcher, 4.8–5.4 in
  11. Red-winged Blackbird, 6.7–9.1 in
  12. Red-headed Woodpecker, 7.5–9.1 in
Drawn for this page from the All About Birds lengths in the chart above; each bar runs from the shortest to the longest published length, and a short marker means a single published length. The cardinal and Pyrrhuloxia are about the size of each other; the Painted Bunting and Vermilion Flycatcher are the smallest.

Red bird with black wings? A quick key

  • Red body, black wings and tail, no crest: a breeding male Scarlet Tanager. After nesting, males turn yellow-green but keep the black wings (All About Birds).
  • All red, no black anywhere, thick pale bill: Summer Tanager, which All About Birds calls the only completely red bird in North America.
  • Red with a crest and a black face: Northern Cardinal. Gray with red trim and a crest, yellow bill: Pyrrhuloxia (All About Birds).
  • Small, orange-red with a dark brown mask, back and wings, on a low open perch: Vermilion Flycatcher (All About Birds).
  • Red head only, on a black-and-white woodpecker: Red-headed Woodpecker. Black bird with red shoulder patches: male Red-winged Blackbird.
  • Red on the head and breast of a streaky brown bird: a red finch. House Finch is red mostly on the eyebrow and throat, with streaked flanks; Purple Finch is evenly washed with dull red; Cassin's has a peaked red crown; crossbills have crossed bill tips (All About Birds, Audubon). The types of finches page compares them in detail.

Cardinal and Pyrrhuloxia

Northern Cardinal

8.3–9.1 in · the year-round red bird

Adult male Northern Cardinal on a weathered wooden fence: bright red body, crest, black face around a thick red-orange bill
Male Northern Cardinal: crest, thick bill and black face.
Photo: Joshua J. Cotten on Unsplash
  • Look for: a long-tailed songbird with a short, very thick bill and a prominent crest; males brilliant red with a black face, females pale brown with warm red in the wings, tail and crest (All About Birds).
  • Where: all year; it does not migrate and does not molt into a dull plumage, so males stay bright in winter (All About Birds, Audubon).
  • In the yard: nearly any feeder attracts it, sunflower especially; undergrowth may bring a nesting pair (All About Birds). Song, nest and look-alikes are on the Northern Cardinal profile.

Pyrrhuloxia

8.3 in · the gray desert cardinal

Male Pyrrhuloxia perched on a weathered dead branch: gray body, tall red-tipped crest, red face and a red stripe down the breast, stubby yellow bill
Male Pyrrhuloxia in Texas, as identified on the Commons file page.
Photo: Andy Morffew / CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons
  • Look for: a cardinal-sized, crested gray bird with a stubby, parrot-like yellow bill; males have a red face and crest, a red stripe down the breast and a reddish tail (All About Birds).
  • Where: a year-round resident of desert scrub, mesquite and dry grassland in the Southwest and Texas; winter flocks wander (All About Birds, Audubon).
  • Tell it from a female cardinal: the cardinal's bill is red-orange and its face black; the Pyrrhuloxia's bill is yellow and curved on top (All About Birds).
  • In the yard: sunflower seed, more often taken on the ground or scattered than at a hanging feeder (All About Birds).

The tanagers

Summer Tanager

6.7 in · the all-red one

Male Summer Tanager perched on a thin branch, seen from below: red all over, including wings and tail, with a thick pale bill
Male Summer Tanager on its wintering grounds at Copán Ruinas, Honduras (February 2023). A Quality image on Wikimedia Commons.
Photo: Charles J. Sharp / CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons
  • Look for: a chunky, big-headed songbird with a large, blunt-tipped pale bill; males entirely bright red, females yellow-green (All About Birds). Listen for its pit-ti-tuck call.
  • Where and when: summer; dry open oak, hickory or pine woods in the Southeast, cottonwood-willow streamsides in the Southwest; winters from central Mexico to Bolivia and Brazil (Audubon).
  • In the yard: it hunts bees and wasps high in the trees and may visit backyard berry bushes and fruit trees near woods (All About Birds).

Scarlet Tanager

6.3–6.7 in · the red bird with black wings

Breeding male Scarlet Tanager on a branch among green leaves: brilliant red head and body, black wing and black tail
Breeding male Scarlet Tanager in Liberty State Park, Jersey City, New Jersey (May 2010), as identified on the Commons file page.
Photo: Mike's Birds / CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons
  • Look for: in spring and summer, males brilliant red with black wings and tail; females and fall birds olive-yellow (All About Birds). Its call is a harsh chick-burr.
  • Where and when: mature deciduous forest of the East in summer, especially with oaks; it winters in northern South America, and in migration passes through backyards (All About Birds, Audubon).
  • In the yard: berries are the backyard tip All About Birds gives: blackberries, raspberries, serviceberries, mulberries, chokeberries and more.

The red finches

House Finch

5.1–5.5 in · the red-headed feeder finch

Adult male House Finch on the rim of a green seed feeder with a sunflower seed in its bill: red forehead, eyebrow, throat and breast, brownish cheek
Adult male House Finch at a feeder in Brooklyn, New York (November 2020). A Featured picture on Wikimedia Commons; sex as given on the file page.
Photo: Rhododendrites / CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons
  • Look for: rosy red around the face and upper breast, mostly on the eyebrow and throat, with brownish cheeks and a streaky brown back and belly; some males are orange or yellow, depending on diet (All About Birds).
  • Where: originally a bird of the western US and Mexico; released on Long Island in 1940, it spread across almost all of the eastern US within 50 years (All About Birds).
  • In the yard: small black-oil sunflower seed; a flock can be 50 birds or more (All About Birds). Eye disease and look-alikes: House Finch profile.

Purple Finch

4.7–6.3 in · "dipped in raspberry juice"

Male Purple Finch perched on a branch: raspberry pink-red head, breast and back, pale belly, short conical bill
Male Purple Finch, Cap Tourmente National Wildlife Area, Quebec (May 2011). A Quality image on Wikimedia Commons; sex as given on the file page.
Photo: Cephas / CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons
  • Look for: males evenly washed with dull red on the head and foreparts, without the House Finch's dark side stripes; females have a dark whisker and whitish eyebrow (Audubon). All About Birds calls it a cleaner, more delicately colored House Finch.
  • Where and when: breeds in northern North America and along the West Coast; shows up at feeders irregularly in winter, in numbers that change a lot from year to year (All About Birds).
  • In the yard: black-oil sunflower; conifers may also draw it (All About Birds).

Cassin's Finch

6.3 in · the mountain finch with a red crown

Male Cassin's Finch standing on a rock at the edge of shallow water: bright red crown, pinkish face and breast, streaked brown back
Male Cassin's Finch, as identified on the Commons file page (photo from the Oregon Department of Fish and Wildlife).
Photo: Simon Wray, Oregon Department of Fish and Wildlife / CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons
  • Look for: a peaked head and a long, straight-sided bill; the male is rosy pink and reddest on the crown, the female crisply streaked (All About Birds).
  • Where: evergreen forests of the western mountains up to about 10,000 feet, sometimes lower in winter; it eats pine seeds and aspen buds (All About Birds). It is on Project FeederWatch's list of common feeder birds.

Red Crossbill

5.5–6.7 in · the crossed bill

Male Red Crossbill crouched on a tray feeder: brick-red body, darker wings, crossed bill tips
Male Red Crossbill eating sunflower seeds at a feeder in St. Louis County, Minnesota, as described on the Commons file page.
Photo: Courtney Celley, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons
  • Look for: a stocky finch whose bill tips cross; males brick red with darker wings and tail, females mostly yellowish below (All About Birds).
  • Where: mature conifer forests in mountains and the boreal forest; nomadic flocks follow cone crops, and in irruptions birds turn up in towns and backyards far to the south and east. It sometimes visits sunflower feeders, especially in the West (All About Birds, Audubon). Irruption forecasts are on types of finches.

Other red birds

Painted Bunting

4.7–5.1 in · blue, green and red

Male Painted Bunting perched on a tube seed feeder inside a wire cage: blue head, red eye ring, yellow-green back, red underparts
Male Painted Bunting at a caged seed feeder in Estero, Florida (February 2010), as described on the Commons file page.
Photo: Mike's Birds / CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons
  • Look for: males with a blue head, green back and red underparts; females and young bright yellow-green with a pale eyering (All About Birds).
  • Where and when: breeds in the coastal Southeast and the south-central US; Atlantic Coast birds winter in Florida and the Caribbean, western birds in Mexico and Central America (All About Birds, Audubon).
  • In the yard: seeds, especially from midsummer; it is more likely to visit a feeder in a yard with low, dense plants (All About Birds). Audubon notes some Floridians see it at feeders in winter, and that trapping for the cage-bird trade on its wintering grounds is a concern.

Vermilion Flycatcher

4.8–5.4 in · a red flycatcher of the Southwest

Male Vermilion Flycatcher on top of a spiny stem: orange-red crown and underparts, dark brown mask through the eye, dark brown back, wings and tail
Male Vermilion Flycatcher in Arizona (April 2017), as identified on the Commons file page.
Photo: Andy Reago & Chrissy McClarren / CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons
  • Look for: a small, upright flycatcher; males brilliant orange-red with a dark brown mask, back, wings and tail; females gray-brown with a salmon-red blush below (All About Birds).
  • Where and when: fairly common in the Southwest, much more often near water; birds from northern and higher areas often leave in winter, and a few winter along the Gulf Coast and near the California coast (All About Birds, Audubon).
  • In the yard: no feeder food; it sallies for flying insects from perches within about 10 feet of the ground (All About Birds).

Red-winged Blackbird

6.7–9.1 in · red shoulders on a black bird

Male Red-winged Blackbird calling with bill open on a boardwalk rail: glossy black body, red shoulder patch with a yellow lower border and a slender pointed bill
Male Red-winged Blackbird calling, John Heinz National Wildlife Refuge, Philadelphia (May 2026). A Featured picture on Wikimedia Commons; species and sex as given on the file page.
Photo: Chuck Homler, Focus On Wildlife / CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons
  • Look for: males glossy black with scarlet-and-yellow shoulder patches they can puff up or hide; females streaky brown (All About Birds).
  • Where: marshes, roadsides and wires across much of the continent; flocks in fields in winter (All About Birds, Audubon).
  • In the yard: mixed grains and seeds scattered on the ground, especially in migration (All About Birds). It is compared with grackles and starlings on starling vs grackle.

Red-headed Woodpecker

7.5–9.1 in · the "flying checkerboard"

Red-headed Woodpecker clinging below a mesh feeder: all-red head, white underparts, black back and tail, large white wing patch
Red-headed Woodpecker at the feeders behind the visitor centre in Rondeau Provincial Park, Ontario (May 2007). A Featured picture on Wikimedia Commons.
Photo: Mdf / CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons
  • Look for: a bright-red head, white underparts and a black back with big white wing patches; sexes alike, young birds gray-brown headed (All About Birds). The Red-bellied Woodpecker is the common look-alike.
  • Where: open woods, farmland groves and town shade trees in the East and Plains; northern and western birds winter in the Southeast (Audubon). It has declined severely in the past half-century (All About Birds).
  • In the yard: occasionally comes to feeders in winter, especially suet (All About Birds). More woodpeckers: types of woodpeckers.

Why red birds are red

Red in these birds is pigment from food. The Cornell Lab's Bird Academy explains that the cardinal's red comes from carotenoids, which birds acquire by eating plants or something that ate a plant. All About Birds adds that birds can't make bright red or yellow colors directly, so a male House Finch's red depends on the pigment in what he eats during molt: the more pigment, the redder the bird, which is why some males are orange or yellow. Females prefer the reddest males.

That is the opposite of blue birds, whose color is made by feather structure (see types of blue birds).

Attracting red birds to your yard

  1. Sunflower for cardinals, finches and the Pyrrhuloxia. Black-oil sunflower is "among the favorite feeder foods of cardinals" and finches (Project FeederWatch); All About Birds names it for House and Purple Finches.
  2. Safflower as a second seed. It attracts cardinals and other big-billed birds, though most birds prefer sunflower (FeederWatch). For squirrel trouble, see squirrel-proof bird feeders.
  3. Seed low or on the ground for Pyrrhuloxias and Red-winged Blackbirds, which feed there more than at hanging feeders (All About Birds).
  4. Berry plants for tanagers. Neither tanager is a feeder bird; Scarlet Tanagers take blackberries, raspberries, serviceberries and mulberries, and Summer Tanagers visit berry bushes and fruit trees (All About Birds). See native plants for birds.
  5. Dense shrubs. Cardinals nest in tangles and undergrowth, and Painted Buntings come to feeders in yards with low, dense cover (All About Birds).

Sources