Independent birding guide — not affiliated with the original Bird-a-Day challenge or the domain's previous owner.
Birdaday Field Notes

ID guide

Types of finches at US feeders: 10 finches, field marks and foods

Updated

The finches you are most likely to see at a US feeder are the American Goldfinch and the House Finch, which between them cover most of the country, plus the Lesser Goldfinch and Cassin's Finch in the West and the Purple Finch, which winters across the central and southeastern states. In some winters the northern "winter finches" (Pine Siskin, Redpoll, Evening Grosbeak and the Red and White-winged Crossbills) move far south of their usual range when seed crops fail in the boreal forest. The chart below sorts all ten by size, field marks, feeder food and how often they irrupt.

A quick rule from the foods: the small-billed goldfinches, siskins and redpolls are the birds that nyjer ("thistle") seed attracts, while black-oil sunflower is a favorite of finches in general (Project FeederWatch). One name has changed: in 2024 the American Ornithological Society merged Common, Hoary and Lesser Redpoll into a single species called simply Redpoll (All About Birds), so older feeder guides still say "Common Redpoll."

Jump to: Chart · Sizes · Quick key · American Goldfinch · Lesser Goldfinch · House Finch · Purple Finch · Cassin's Finch · Pine Siskin · Redpoll · Evening Grosbeak · Red Crossbill · White-winged Crossbill · Irruption years · Feeding finches

Types of finches chart: field marks, feeder foods and irruptions

Finch Length Adult male Female and young Where in the US Feeder food Irruptive?
American Goldfinch 4.3–5.1 in Summer: bright yellow with black forehead, wings and tail. Winter: yellowish-brown to gray with bold wingbars Duller yellow-green in summer Across the country Nyjer; small seeds No; an irregular migrant
Lesser Goldfinch 3.5–4.3 in Yellow below, glossy black cap, white wing patches; back black or dull green Olive back, dull yellow below, two whitish wingbars The West; resident in much of its range Seeds at feeders No
House Finch 5.1–5.5 in Red eyebrow, forehead, throat and chest against a brown cap; some orange or yellow Plain brown face, blurry streaks below Nearly everywhere: native to the Southwest, now in the East too Sunflower; also sugar water No
Purple Finch 4.7–6.3 in Pink-red head and breast, brown back, cloudy white belly No red; coarse streaks, whitish eyebrow, dark line down the throat side Breeds in Canada and along the Pacific Coast; winters across the central and southeastern US Black-oil sunflower Yes; erratic, follows cone crops
Cassin's Finch 6.3 in Rosy pink with a brighter red, peaked crown Brown and white with crisp dark streaks; streaked undertail coverts Western mountain conifer forests; lower in winter Mostly buds and pine seeds; listed as a common feeder bird Nomadic
Pine Siskin 4.3–5.5 in Sexes alike: brown and very streaky, yellow edging on wings and tail, thin pointed bill Like the adult Conifer forests; south in huge numbers in some winters Nyjer; black-oil sunflower in tubes Yes
Redpoll 4.5–5.5 in Small red forehead patch, black around a yellow bill, two white wingbars, rosy breast Brown and streaky with a tiny red cap Arctic and boreal; northern US feeders in irruption winters Nyjer; black-oil sunflower Yes
Evening Grosbeak 6.3–7.1 in Yellow and black, big white wing patch, bright yellow eyebrow, huge pale bill Mostly gray, white-and-black wings, greenish-yellow neck and flanks Northern forests and western mountains; south in some winters Sunflower, on platforms or hoppers Yes
Red Crossbill 5.5–6.7 in Brick red with darker wings and tail; crossed bill Yellowish below, olive-brown above Mountain and boreal conifer forests; nomadic Conifer seeds; sometimes sunflower, mostly in the West Yes
White-winged Crossbill 6–7 in Rose-red with broad white wingbars on black wings Dull yellow with blurry streaks Boreal spruce forests Spruce seeds; rarely at feeders Yes

Lengths: All About Birds (Cornell Lab of Ornithology) identification pages; the two crossbills from Audubon's field guide, as All About Birds gives no Red Crossbill length. Field marks: All About Birds and Audubon. Foods: Project FeederWatch, All About Birds, Audubon and the Finch Research Network forecast. "Irruptive" means flocks move far south in some winters and stay north in others.

Finch sizes compared

Lengths of ten US feeder finches on one inch scaleHorizontal bars on a 3 to 7.5 inch scale, numbered 1 to 10 in the order of the chart: 1 American Goldfinch 4.3 to 5.1 inches; 2 Lesser Goldfinch 3.5 to 4.3 inches; 3 House Finch 5.1 to 5.5 inches; 4 Purple Finch 4.7 to 6.3 inches; 5 Cassin's Finch 6.3 inches; 6 Pine Siskin 4.3 to 5.5 inches; 7 Redpoll 4.5 to 5.5 inches; 8 Evening Grosbeak 6.3 to 7.1 inches; 9 Red Crossbill 5.5 to 6.7 inches; 10 White-winged Crossbill 6 to 7 inches. A single published length is drawn as a dot.3 in4 in5 in6 in7 in12345678910
  1. American Goldfinch: 4.3–5.1 in
  2. Lesser Goldfinch: 3.5–4.3 in
  3. House Finch: 5.1–5.5 in
  4. Purple Finch: 4.7–6.3 in
  5. Cassin's Finch: 6.3 in
  6. Pine Siskin: 4.3–5.5 in
  7. Redpoll: 4.5–5.5 in
  8. Evening Grosbeak: 6.3–7.1 in
  9. Red Crossbill: 5.5–6.7 in
  10. White-winged Crossbill: 6–7 in
Drawn for this page from the lengths in the chart (All About Birds; Audubon for the crossbills). Bars show each published length range; Cassin's Finch has a single published length, drawn as a dot.

The goldfinches, siskin and redpoll are tiny; House, Purple and Cassin's Finches are about House Sparrow size; the Evening Grosbeak is about Northern Cardinal size but stockier (All About Birds).

Which finch is it? A quick key

  • Mostly yellow: American Goldfinch (black forehead and wings in summer), Lesser Goldfinch (glossy black cap, white wing patches, black or green back) or, if it is cardinal-sized with a huge pale bill and a yellow eyebrow, an Evening Grosbeak.
  • Red or pink on a brown bird: House Finch (red headband against a brown cap, streaked flanks), Purple Finch (pink-red wash over head, breast and back), Cassin's Finch (peaked red crown; western mountains), Redpoll (red only on the forehead, black around a yellow bill) or a crossbill (crossed bill tips).
  • Brown and streaky: a female House, Purple or Cassin's Finch; a Pine Siskin (thin, sharply pointed bill and yellow flashes in the wings); or a female Redpoll (tiny red cap).

Females of House, Purple and Cassin's Finch are the hardest trio; the House Finch profile compares them side by side, and terms such as wingbar are labeled on the parts of a bird diagram.

Goldfinches

American Goldfinch

4.3–5.1 in · the nyjer-feeder regular

Male American Goldfinch in summer plumage perched among green leaves: bright yellow body, black cap, black wings with white bars
American Goldfinch in July, Pleasant Valley Wildlife Sanctuary, Lenox, Massachusetts. A Quality image on Wikimedia Commons; species as given on the file page.
Photo: Paul Danese / CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons
  • Look for: the summer male is bright yellow with black wings, tail and forehead; females are duller yellow-green; winter birds are yellowish-brown to gray with bold white or buff wingbars and white tail spots (Audubon).
  • Where and when: across the country; "irregular in migration, with more remaining in the North in winters with good food supply" (Audubon).
  • At feeders: commonly comes to feeders for small seeds (Audubon), and nyjer is the classic draw (FeederWatch).
  • More: molt calendar and nesting on the American Goldfinch profile.

Lesser Goldfinch

3.5–4.3 in · the western goldfinch

Lesser Goldfinch perched on a thin twig: olive back and head without a black cap, yellow underparts, dark wings with pale bars
Lesser Goldfinch on the Sacramento River west of Chico, California (August 2022). The olive crown and back with no black cap match the female/immature pattern All About Birds describes; the file page does not give the sex. A Quality image on Wikimedia Commons.
Photo: Frank Schulenburg / CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons
  • Look for: males are yellow below with a glossy black cap and white wing patches; the back is black at the eastern edge of the range and dull green farther west. Females are olive above and dull yellow below; a white wing patch separates them from female American Goldfinches (All About Birds).
  • Where and when: a permanent resident in much of its western range (Audubon); in mountain canyons, desert oases and fairly commonly in suburbs (All About Birds).
  • At feeders: groups of up to several hundred feed on seeds in weedy fields and at feeders (All About Birds); wild favorites are thistle and wild sunflower (Audubon).

House, Purple and Cassin's Finches

House Finch

5.1–5.5 in · the red-headed feeder finch

Adult male House Finch on the rim of a green seed feeder with a sunflower seed in its bill: red forehead, eyebrow, throat and breast, brownish cheek
Adult male House Finch at a feeder in Brooklyn, New York (November 2020). A Featured picture on Wikimedia Commons; sex as given on the file page.
Photo: Rhododendrites / CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons
  • Look for: the male's red eyebrow and forehead contrast with a brown cap; throat and chest are red, orange or yellow; females and young have plain brown faces and blurry stripes below (Audubon). Same size as a House Sparrow but slimmer (All About Birds).
  • Where and when: native to the Southwest; pet shop owners released birds in New York in 1940, and within about 50 years the eastern population met the western one on the Great Plains (Audubon).
  • At feeders: seeds, especially sunflower, and sometimes sugar water at hummingbird feeders (Audubon).
  • More: eye disease and the Purple and Cassin's comparison on the House Finch profile.

Purple Finch

4.7–6.3 in · the raspberry-washed wanderer

Male Purple Finch perched on a branch: raspberry pink-red head, breast and back, pale belly, short conical bill
Male Purple Finch, Cap Tourmente National Wildlife Area, Quebec (May 2011). A Quality image on Wikimedia Commons; sex as given on the file page.
Photo: Cephas / CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons
  • Look for: males are pink-red on the head and breast, mixing with brown on the back; females have no red, coarse streaks and a whitish eyestripe with a dark line down the side of the throat (All About Birds). Pacific Coast birds are duller (All About Birds).
  • Where and when: breeds in Canada's conifer and mixed forests and along the Pacific Coast; an erratic migrant that follows cone crops, wintering widely across the central and southeastern US and returning to a given region roughly every other year (All About Birds).
  • At feeders: readily comes for black-oil sunflower (All About Birds).

Cassin's Finch

6.3 in · the mountain finch

Male Cassin's Finch standing on a rock at the edge of shallow water: bright red crown, pinkish face and breast, streaked brown back
Male Cassin's Finch, as identified on the Commons file page (photo from the Oregon Department of Fish and Wildlife).
Photo: Simon Wray, Oregon Department of Fish and Wildlife / CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons
  • Look for: a peaked head and a long, straight-sided bill; the male is rosy pink, reddest on the crown; both sexes have streaked undertail coverts (All About Birds).
  • Where and when: evergreen mountain forests up to about 10,000 feet, moving lower in winter (All About Birds); "somewhat nomadic," irregular in the lowlands and sometimes out onto the plains (Audubon).
  • At feeders: feeds mainly on tree buds and pine seeds (All About Birds); Project FeederWatch includes it in its list of common feeder birds.

Winter finches

These five breed in northern or mountain forests and come south in numbers only in some winters (see irruption years).

Pine Siskin

4.3–5.5 in · the streaky nyjer lover

Pine Siskin perched on a branch: brown, heavily streaked body, thin sharply pointed bill, yellow edging on the wing
Pine Siskin in Green-Wood Cemetery, Brooklyn, New York (November 2020, an irruption winter). A Featured picture on Wikimedia Commons.
Photo: Rhododendrites / CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons
  • Look for: brown and very streaky with subtle yellow edging on the wings and tail that flashes in flight; a bill more slender than most finches'; slightly smaller than an American Goldfinch (All About Birds).
  • Where and when: evergreen and mixed forests; "coming south in huge numbers some years, very scarce in others" (Audubon).
  • At feeders: especially thistle (nyjer) feeders, often with American Goldfinches (All About Birds; Audubon); the Finch Research Network adds black-oil sunflower in tube feeders.

Redpoll

4.5–5.5 in · formerly Common and Hoary Redpoll

Male redpoll of the Common form on a twig: small red forehead patch, black around a short yellow bill, rosy pink breast, streaked gray-brown flanks
Male of the "Common" form, Cap Tourmente National Wildlife Area, Quebec (February 2010), labeled Common Redpoll on the file page. A Featured picture on Wikimedia Commons.
Photo: Cephas / CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons
  • Look for: a small red forehead patch, two white wingbars and black feathering around a yellow bill. The "Common" form is brown with heavily streaked sides, the male with a rosy breast; the "Hoary" form is pale and whitish (All About Birds).
  • Where and when: arctic tundra and boreal forest; often visits feeders when populations irrupt south to the northern US and southern Canada (All About Birds).
  • At feeders: nyjer and black-oil sunflower, and birches and weedy fields nearby (Finch Research Network; FeederWatch).

Evening Grosbeak

6.3–7.1 in · the sunflower crusher

Male Evening Grosbeak on a branch against blue sky: dark head with a bright yellow eyebrow, thick pale bill, mustard-yellow body, black wings and tail
Evening Grosbeak, Cap Tourmente National Wildlife Area, Quebec (February 2010). A Featured picture on Wikimedia Commons.
Photo: Cephas / CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons
  • Look for: a large, heavyset finch with a very thick bill that is pale ivory in winter and greenish by late March; males yellow and black with a white wing patch and a bright yellow eyebrow; females mostly gray (All About Birds).
  • Where and when: breeds in northern and western mountain forests and makes "very erratic movements south" in some winters (All About Birds). The eastern population has declined heavily in recent decades (Audubon).
  • At feeders: "very fond of sunflower seeds" (Audubon), on platform or hopper feeders (Finch Research Network).

Red Crossbill

5.5–6.7 in · the cone specialist

Male Red Crossbill crouched on a tray feeder: brick-red body, darker wings, crossed bill tips
Male Red Crossbill eating sunflower seeds at a feeder in St. Louis County, Minnesota, as described on the Commons file page.
Photo: Courtney Celley, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons
  • Look for: a stocky finch whose bill tips cross when closed; males brick red with darker wings and tail, females yellowish below and olive-brown above (All About Birds).
  • Where and when: mature conifer forests in the mountains and the boreal forest; in irruptions flocks turn up in towns and backyards far south and east of the usual range (All About Birds).
  • At feeders: sometimes takes sunflower seed, especially in the West (All About Birds); "very attracted to salt" (Audubon).

White-winged Crossbill

6–7 in · the spruce specialist

Male White-winged Crossbill on the ground: rose-red body, black wings with two broad white wingbars, crossed bill
Male White-winged Crossbill, Mount Auburn Cemetery, Massachusetts, as given on the Commons file page.
Photo: John Harrison / CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons
  • Look for: broad white bars on black wings; males mostly rose-red, females dull yellow with blurry streaks. A Red Crossbill sometimes shows very thin wingbars (Audubon).
  • Where and when: spruce forests of the North; "no regular migration, but flocks may travel long distances at any season in search of good cone crops" (Audubon).
  • At feeders: feeds mostly on spruce seeds in the cones; Audubon's guide does not mention feeders.

Irruption years: when winter finches come south

An irruption happens when seed or fruit crops fail in the boreal forest and finches move south to find food (Audubon). The Finch Research Network's annual Winter Finch Forecast builds on work by Ian Newton and Ron Pittaway linking summer cone crops to winter numbers of siskins, crossbills and grosbeaks.

Winter finch forecast 2026–27 at a glance

Finch East and Northeast (forecast, September 2026) Central and West (irruption alert, October 2026)
Pine Siskin Sizable irruption held in the Northeast; small to moderate flight to the Southeast possible At least a moderate irruption through the central US to Texas; strong winter in the Pacific valleys of Washington, Oregon and California
Redpoll No big flight expected; a small one possible, mainly in the western Great Lakes No large irruption into the central or western states
Evening Grosbeak Small to medium flocks; possibly south to southern New York, Pennsylvania and Massachusetts Very large irruption into lowlands of the Interior West; large movement onto the western Great Plains
Purple Finch Many in eastern Canada, the Great Lakes and the Northeast; a late, small flight south at best A small, possibly late irruption (late November to January); western birds less irruptive
Red Crossbill Type 12 to dominate in the Northeast, Type 2 in the western Great Lakes Type 2 irrupting onto the Plains and into lower western forests
White-winged Crossbill Small to moderate push in the East Small numbers in mountain spruce forests; no major Northwest flight like 2017 or 2021

Sources: Finch Research Network, Winter Finch Forecast 2026–2027 (Tyler Hoar) and its central and western irruption alert (Matt Young and Caleb Centanni), which expect many finches to stay in conifer forests with good seed rather than at feeders. Report what you see in eBird; Red Crossbill call recordings uploaded there help identify the types.

Feeding finches: nyjer, sunflower and clean feeders

  1. Nyjer for the small-billed finches. American Goldfinch, Pine Siskin and redpolls come to nyjer. The seed is so small that it needs a feeder with very small ports, and it is best fed by itself rather than in a mix, to cut waste (FeederWatch). The nyjer feeder section shows tube and sock styles; other seeds are in what to feed backyard birds. Siskins favor nyjer in silo or sock feeders (Finch Research Network).
  2. Black-oil sunflower for the rest. It is a favorite of finches in general; hulled sunflower cuts the chaff under feeders but spoils faster, so keep it dry (FeederWatch). Purple Finches and Evening Grosbeaks prefer black-oil sunflower, the grosbeaks on platforms or hoppers (Finch Research Network).
  3. Keep feeders clean, especially in irruption winters. Salmonellosis outbreaks occasionally kill large numbers of Pine Siskins, redpolls and American Goldfinches and spreads mainly through droppings in food and water (FeederWatch). Follow the steps in how to clean a bird feeder; for swollen-eyed House Finches see the House Finch profile.
  4. Stock up when a flight is forecast. Audubon's advice for a superflight winter: keep feeders stocked and maybe buy backup seed. More cold-weather tips are in winter bird feeding.

Sources