Independent birding guide — not affiliated with the original Bird-a-Day challenge or the domain's previous owner.
Birdaday Field Notes

Feeding guide

Safflower seed for birds: which birds eat it, which usually don't, and how to offer it

Updated

Northern Cardinals, chickadees, titmice, nuthatches, House Finches, doves and some native sparrows eat safflower, and Project FeederWatch lists 25 common feeder species that take it (FeederWatch; All About Birds). It is less attractive to grackles, starlings, House Sparrows and squirrels (UNL Extension), but the sources say "usually," not always, and FeederWatch notes that most birds still prefer sunflower.

Safflower is grown for its oil and for bird seed and looks like a white sunflower seed (FeederWatch).

Jump to: Chart · Who usually leaves it alone · Safflower vs sunflower · Feeders · Golden safflower · If birds ignore it · Storing · Checklist

Which birds eat safflower: chart

Rows marked FeederWatch come from the safflower filter of Project FeederWatch's Common Feeder Birds tool (25 of its 97 species, read November 20, 2026), which also lists the feeder types each species uses.

Bird Eats safflower? Feeders it uses (FeederWatch) Notes
Northern Cardinal Yes, "a favorite" (All About Birds; UF/IFAS); listed by FeederWatch Ground, large hopper, large tube, platform Audubon still calls black-oil sunflower the best bet for cardinals; they "gladly nibble" safflower too
Chickadees: Black-capped, Carolina, Mountain, Chestnut-backed, Boreal Yes (FeederWatch; All About Birds; UNL) Hoppers, tubes, platform, suet cage UNL lists it among the Black-capped Chickadee's favorites, after oil-type sunflower and nutmeats
Titmice: Tufted, Black-crested, Oak, Juniper Yes (FeederWatch; UF/IFAS) Hoppers, tubes, platform, suet cage
White-breasted Nuthatch Yes (FeederWatch; UF/IFAS; UNL) Hoppers, tubes, platform, suet cage FeederWatch does not list safflower for the Red-breasted Nuthatch
House Finch Yes (FeederWatch; UNL) Hoppers, tubes, platform Not listed for Purple Finch, Pine Siskin or American Goldfinch, whose FeederWatch foods are sunflower and nyjer
Grosbeaks "Some grosbeaks" (All About Birds); a favorite (UF/IFAS); Audubon names the Evening Grosbeak Not given Sources differ: FeederWatch's Evening Grosbeak entry lists only sunflower
Mourning Dove, Rock Pigeon Yes (FeederWatch; All About Birds "doves"; UNL) Ground, large hopper, platform
Dark-eyed Junco, Song Sparrow, Golden-crowned Sparrow Yes (FeederWatch); "native sparrows" (All About Birds); "some safflower" (UNL) Ground, platform; junco also large hopper Not listed for the White-throated Sparrow
Woodpeckers: Downy, Hairy, Red-bellied, Northern Flicker Listed by FeederWatch Large hopper, platform, suet cage More in types of woodpeckers
Blue Jay Listed by FeederWatch Ground, large hopper, large tube, platform, suet cage Steller's Jay is not listed
Wild Turkey Listed by FeederWatch Ground, platform
Common and Great-tailed Grackle Listed by FeederWatch Ground, large hopper, platform Other sources say grackles usually avoid it: see the next table

For every other seed in one chart, see what to feed backyard birds.

Who usually leaves safflower alone

Visitor What the sources say
House Sparrow Not on FeederWatch's safflower list. All About Birds: "according to some sources" it doesn't like safflower, but in some areas it seems to have developed a taste for it. UNL: usually avoids it
European Starling Not on FeederWatch's safflower list; the same All About Birds and UNL caveats apply
Grackles UNL: usually avoid it, "but this may not always be the case"; UF/IFAS Lake County Extension calls safflower a deterrent. FeederWatch lists both Common and Great-tailed Grackle as safflower eaters
Cowbirds, Red-winged and Brewer's Blackbirds Not on FeederWatch's safflower list. All About Birds: safflower's thick, hard shell is harder for blackbirds to crack
Squirrels UNL and UF/IFAS: usually avoid it. All About Birds: in some areas they seem to have developed a taste for it

So safflower works as a filter, not a wall. When starlings crowd in, All About Birds adds that starlings find tube feeders difficult; for telling the black birds apart, see starling vs grackle, and for baffles and distances, squirrel-proof bird feeders.

Safflower vs sunflower

A glass dish full of pale beige safflower seeds on display above a museum label reading Carthamus tinctorius
Safflower (Carthamus tinctorius) seeds on display at the Osaka Museum of Natural History, as identified on the Commons file page.
Photo: Daderot, public domain (CC0), via Wikimedia Commons
Black-oil sunflower Striped sunflower Safflower
Shell Very thin; easy for virtually all seed-eating birds to crack (All About Birds) Thicker; much harder for House Sparrows and blackbirds (All About Birds) Thicker than black-oil (UF/IFAS); hard for some birds to open (All About Birds)
Who it draws Most birds prefer sunflower to safflower (FeederWatch); the best all-around seed (OSU Extension) Cardinals' next favorite after black-oil in one study (Audubon) Cardinals, chickadees, titmice, nuthatches, House Finches and the others in the chart
Squirrels Very attractive to them (All About Birds) Same Usually avoided (UNL; UF/IFAS)
Taste Bitter (UF/IFAS Lake County Extension)
Three feeder seeds compared by shellThree seeds drawn side by side, each cut open to show its shell as a band around the kernel. Left: a small black-oil sunflower seed with a thin black shell. Middle: a larger striped sunflower seed with a thicker gray-and-black striped shell. Right: a white safflower seed with a thick white shell. Numbered badges match the list below the drawing. Black-oil sunflower Striped sunflower Safflower 1 2 3
  1. Black-oil sunflower: a very thin shell that virtually all seed-eating birds can crack (All About Birds).
  2. Striped sunflower: a thicker shell, much harder for House Sparrows and blackbirds (All About Birds).
  3. Safflower: looks like a white sunflower seed (FeederWatch), with a shell thicker than black-oil sunflower (UF/IFAS) that is hard for some birds to open but a cardinal favorite (All About Birds).
Drawn for Birdaday Field Notes from All About Birds, Project FeederWatch and UF/IFAS Extension, all cited below. Not to scale; shell thickness is shown schematically.

Feeders for safflower

Feeder styles are compared in bird feeder types.

Golden and hulled safflower

Regular safflower can be messy because the hulls pile up under the feeder (UNL). Hulled and thin-hulled kinds, such as the "golden safflower" sold as NutraSaff, are said to reduce waste and may be preferred by birds over traditional safflower, according to the same UNL publication. No other source we read compared them.

If birds ignore it

  1. Check the seed. Answering a reader whose birds ignored golden safflower, Oregon State University Extension suggested that big-box seed may not be the freshest and pointed to bird-feeding specialty stores, which go through seed quickly and often guarantee it.
  2. Check who visits. The same answer notes safflower may not suit the birds at your feeders. FeederWatch's Common Feeder Birds tool filters by winter region and food, so you can see which of your regulars take it; goldfinches, for example, are not on its safflower list.
  3. Keep sunflower too. Most birds prefer sunflower (FeederWatch), and OSU Extension calls black-oil sunflower the best all-around seed. Offer it in its own feeder (Audubon).
  4. Skip mixes. OSU Extension advises avoiding mixed seed, because by weight you pay mostly for filler that birds scatter uneaten.

Storing safflower

Audubon's guide to bird feeding suggests storing seed in metal garbage cans with secure lids to keep squirrels and mice out, keeping the cans cool and dry and out of the heat, and not keeping seed from one winter to the next. Cleaning routines are in how to clean a bird feeder.

Safflower checklist

Sources